CASP1 - CASP9
(* results recalculated with new /updated structure comparison programs in 2019)
Menu
`
TS Analysis : Z-score based relative group performance

    Models:

    • Ranking on the models designated as "1"
    • Ranking on best models

    Groups:

    • All groups on 'all groups' targets
    • Server groups on 'all groups' + 'server only' targets

    Formula and Domains:

      The ranking of groups is based on the analysis of zscores for GDT_TS.
    • easy (TBM)
    • medium (TBM/FM)
    • hard (FM)
 
 
  #   GR
  code 		   GR
  name		   Domains   
  Count		   SUM Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   Rank SUM Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   AVG Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   Rank AVG Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   SUM Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   Rank SUM Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   AVG Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   Rank AVG Zscore   
  (>0.0)
1 006 BioInfo.PL 78 62.4920 2 0.8012 6 66.1340 1 0.8479 7
2 002 BAKER 65 63.1520 1 0.9716 2 64.5420 2 0.9930 4
3 453 Ginalski 69 61.0820 3 0.8852 5 63.9190 3 0.9264 5
4 010 Skolnick-Kolinski 74 56.8140 4 0.7678 9 59.0820 4 0.7984 9
5 517 GeneSilico 68 48.8870 5 0.7189 11 52.7040 5 0.7751 10
6 153 CHIMERA 72 43.7480 8 0.6076 16 51.8890 6 0.7207 12
7 224 3D-SHOTGUN-3DS5 80 46.3560 6 0.5795 18 50.8130 7 0.6352 18
8 001 SAM-T02-human 80 40.9500 10 0.5119 25 47.8210 8 0.5978 23
9 020 Bujnicki-Janusz 57 43.7900 7 0.7682 8 47.1770 9 0.8277 8
10 223 3D-SHOTGUN-3DS3 80 39.7760 12 0.4972 29 46.4680 10 0.5808 26
11 045 Pmodel3 80 33.2840 21 0.4160 42 46.4140 11 0.5802 27
12 040 Pmodel 80 35.0980 16 0.4387 35 45.4270 12 0.5678 30
13 012 ORNL-PROSPECT 72 41.1190 9 0.5711 19 45.0140 13 0.6252 20
14 112 Friesner 76 39.0820 13 0.5142 23 44.6530 14 0.5875 25
15 084 SBC 79 33.5280 20 0.4244 40 43.5880 15 0.5517 35
16 427 FISCHER 63 40.2030 11 0.6381 14 43.3190 16 0.6876 15
17 265 Sasson-Iris 78 34.8380 17 0.4466 34 42.8700 17 0.5496 36
18 096 Bates-Paul 74 36.2700 15 0.4901 30 41.9880 18 0.5674 31
19 029 BAKER-ROBETTA 61 38.4360 14 0.6301 15 41.6960 19 0.6835 16
20 242 GeneSilico.PL-servers-only 69 34.4230 18 0.4989 27 41.2960 20 0.5985 22
21 067 Jones 67 34.3780 19 0.5131 24 40.5520 21 0.6053 21
22 373 Brooks 80 31.3260 25 0.3916 46 40.3260 22 0.5041 42
23 222 3D-SHOTGUN-INBGU 80 33.2260 22 0.4153 43 38.7620 23 0.4845 48
24 170 CHIMERAX 80 30.2810 26 0.3785 48 36.8340 24 0.4604 53
25 110 Honig 50 32.3940 23 0.6479 13 35.5570 25 0.7111 13
26 028 Celltech 59 29.5930 27 0.5016 26 34.7220 26 0.5885 24
27 288 Lomize-Andrei 65 27.6570 29 0.4255 38 34.5250 27 0.5312 39
28 041 CBRC 69 24.2560 33 0.3515 52 34.4700 28 0.4996 43
29 368 José 68 25.5320 32 0.3755 50 34.4590 29 0.5068 41
30 349 Shortle 25 26.4900 30 1.0596 1 34.1730 30 1.3669 1
31 144 RAPTOR 80 10.5360 63 0.1317 82 34.1330 31 0.4267 59
32 450 TOME 54 31.9710 24 0.5921 17 33.9070 32 0.6279 19
33 447 Cam-Biochem 68 26.0570 31 0.3832 47 33.8270 33 0.4975 45
34 039 Pcons3 80 12.1450 55 0.1518 76 33.4580 34 0.4182 63
35 194 BioInfo.PL-ORFeus 80 7.1880 72 0.0898 92 33.3890 35 0.4174 64
36 105 Sternberg 70 28.7420 28 0.4106 44 33.2610 36 0.4752 51
37 208 BioInfo.PL-BasicB 80 12.6030 53 0.1575 75 32.4730 37 0.4059 69
38 286 3DSN-INBGU 80 14.4690 46 0.1809 71 32.4480 38 0.4056 70
39 537 NEC-asogawa 72 9.8880 65 0.1318 81 31.5290 39 0.4204 61
40 228 Mishali-Amir 74 21.4960 36 0.2905 58 31.5070 40 0.4258 60
41 329 Dunbrack 55 23.5100 34 0.4275 36 31.3940 41 0.5708 29
42 016 Levitt 68 21.7080 35 0.3192 57 30.7790 42 0.4526 54
43 229 3D-PSSM 80 10.5630 62 0.1320 80 30.2850 43 0.3786 78
44 080 Bilab 78 17.0420 43 0.2185 63 29.8650 44 0.3829 76
45 180 evolutionaries 80 6.9260 75 0.0866 93 29.7020 45 0.3713 83
46 099 Camacho-Carlos 80 7.4900 71 0.0936 91 29.5700 46 0.3696 84
47 309 FFAS03 79 5.2490 81 0.0664 96 29.5140 47 0.3736 82
48 226 FUGUE3 80 11.4620 58 0.1415 77 29.3060 48 0.3618 86
49 475 Bionomix 67 14.3410 47 0.2140 64 29.1190 49 0.4346 56
50 233 RAPTOR-1 80 -6.8360 128 -0.0854 109 28.7540 50 0.3594 87
51 014 FUGUE2 80 7.8850 70 0.0973 90 28.4320 51 0.3510 89
52 168 FAMS 80 10.9940 59 0.1374 78 27.8440 52 0.3481 90
53 189 SAM-T02-server 80 -3.0400 111 -0.0375 104 27.8110 53 0.3433 95
54 221 INBGU 80 13.0100 52 0.1626 73 27.7450 54 0.3468 92
55 209 BioInfo.PL-BasicC 80 -7.2930 129 -0.0912 111 27.2540 55 0.3407 96
56 464 ATOME 79 -8.0010 131 -0.1013 113 27.2130 56 0.3445 93
57 046 Pcomb 80 -12.1360 138 -0.1517 118 27.0310 57 0.3379 97
58 078 rost 70 13.7130 49 0.1959 68 26.6500 58 0.3807 77
59 100 SBI 47 18.6740 38 0.3973 45 26.6160 59 0.5663 32
60 183 arby-scai 75 -8.7070 133 -0.1146 115 26.1260 60 0.3438 94
61 202 Yasara-Pushchino 52 17.3820 40 0.3343 55 25.7880 61 0.4959 46
62 203 Pushchino 60 17.3590 41 0.2893 59 25.7610 62 0.4294 57
63 351 Huber-Torda 80 15.5070 45 0.1938 69 25.6570 63 0.3207 102
64 071 mGenTHREADER 80 3.4040 86 0.0425 97 25.0750 64 0.3134 106
65 169 FAMSD 80 -3.6270 114 -0.0453 106 24.5520 65 0.3069 107
66 417 CBSU 61 10.8200 60 0.1774 72 23.9740 66 0.3930 72
67 290 FORTE1 79 -3.5790 113 -0.0453 105 23.3860 67 0.2960 111
68 476 123D_server 60 6.9590 74 0.1160 86 23.1390 68 0.3856 75
69 362 PSPT 77 -5.0880 119 -0.0661 108 23.1100 69 0.3001 109
70 513 Pas 77 0.0110 101 0.0001 101 22.7310 70 0.2952 113
71 291 FFAS 80 -17.6620 146 -0.2208 123 22.6720 71 0.2834 115
72 108 CaspIta 69 9.4380 66 0.1368 79 22.5910 72 0.3274 100
73 448 Murzin 22 20.1490 37 0.9159 3 22.5540 73 1.0252 3
74 359 GEM 53 17.7780 39 0.3354 54 21.9340 74 0.4138 67
75 195 ORNL-PROSPECT 71 8.4150 68 0.1185 85 21.5920 75 0.3041 108
76 056 Zhou-HX 72 7.0540 73 0.0980 89 21.2550 76 0.2952 112
77 024 Braun-Werner 52 17.2800 42 0.3323 56 20.3580 77 0.3915 73
78 423 Taylor 72 5.4480 80 0.0757 94 20.3270 78 0.2823 116
79 047 FROST-MIG 62 6.7060 76 0.1082 87 20.3100 79 0.3276 99
80 068 Jones-NewFold 17 13.2160 50 0.7774 7 20.0780 80 1.1811 2
81 132 I-sites/Bystroff 67 -45.1860 173 -0.6744 153 19.9480 81 0.2977 110
82 301 UCLA-DOE 54 10.6920 61 0.1980 66 19.8390 82 0.3674 85
83 038 Pcons2 80 -15.7770 144 -0.1972 122 19.7530 83 0.2469 126
84 437 Ho-Kai-Ming 71 -12.7740 139 -0.1799 120 19.3390 84 0.2724 120
85 093 Schulten-Wolynes 54 3.9350 83 0.0729 95 18.7710 85 0.3476 91
86 008 CBC-FOLD 71 -4.2150 117 -0.0594 107 18.4240 86 0.2595 122
87 007 SAM-T99 79 -30.3980 165 -0.3800 132 18.1230 87 0.2265 129
88 435 Fujita 25 11.5510 57 0.4620 32 17.7620 88 0.7105 14
89 035 LAMBERT-Christophe 42 14.1390 48 0.3366 53 17.4930 89 0.4165 65
90 025 HMMSPECTR 55 -5.7120 124 -0.1039 114 17.4000 90 0.3164 104
91 207 BioInfo.PL-ORFblast 80 -28.7430 162 -0.3593 129 17.3380 91 0.2167 131
92 246 MZ-Brussels 61 0.2800 99 0.0046 99 17.0670 92 0.2798 117
93 264 CHEN-WENDY 44 10.0730 64 0.2289 62 17.0130 93 0.3867 74
94 425 VENCLOVAS 19 17.0010 44 0.8948 4 17.0010 94 0.8948 6
95 214 Advanced-ONIZUKA 80 -54.8570 181 -0.6857 154 16.9880 95 0.2124 133
96 090 Holm 41 8.0550 69 0.1965 67 16.2050 96 0.3952 71
97 034 ESyPred3D 42 11.7690 56 0.2802 60 15.8610 97 0.3776 79
98 465 POMI 31 13.1680 51 0.4248 39 15.7780 98 0.5090 40
99 234 ALAX 47 6.0170 78 0.1280 83 15.0750 99 0.3207 101
100 327 Rokko 36 0.0790 100 0.0022 100 14.9850 100 0.4163 66
101 230 LIBELLULA 54 -5.1380 121 -0.0951 112 14.7730 101 0.2736 119
102 070 GenTHREADER 80 -20.1910 152 -0.2524 126 14.6830 102 0.1835 139
103 196 BioInfo.PL-PDB-Blast 78 -42.7830 172 -0.5485 141 14.4210 103 0.1849 138
104 135 MPALIGN 80 -48.1250 174 -0.5941 143 14.2630 104 0.1761 143
105 086 SUPFAM_PP 62 -42.4470 171 -0.6738 152 14.2350 105 0.2260 130
106 227 3D-JIGSAW 57 -6.5940 127 -0.1157 116 13.4220 106 0.2355 128
107 065 SUPERFAMILY 72 -48.9190 176 -0.6701 151 13.1170 107 0.1797 142
108 081 AS2TS 27 12.4050 54 0.4594 33 12.9820 108 0.4808 49
109 400 SPAM1 50 -18.6880 149 -0.3738 131 12.5070 109 0.2501 125
110 440 Biogen 29 5.9630 79 0.2056 65 11.9830 110 0.4132 68
111 471 Martin-Andrew 25 9.3640 67 0.3746 51 11.7310 111 0.4692 52
112 531 KIAS 39 -31.5940 166 -0.8101 164 11.2420 112 0.2883 114
113 419 luethy 80 -37.9860 170 -0.4748 139 11.1160 113 0.1389 148
114 347 SDSC2:Reddy-Bourne 61 -22.6460 156 -0.3712 130 10.6480 114 0.1746 144
115 053 SAMUDRALA-CM 78 -48.5050 175 -0.6219 146 9.8040 115 0.1257 151
116 138 PROTINFO-CM 80 -49.8800 178 -0.6235 147 9.7750 116 0.1222 153
117 429 keasar 17 2.6940 90 0.1585 74 9.7670 117 0.5745 28
118 384 Bass-Michael 54 -12.0810 137 -0.2237 124 9.7070 118 0.1798 141
119 032 Pan 48 -19.6530 150 -0.4094 134 9.6530 119 0.2011 136
120 378 PILOT 55 -23.4160 159 -0.4257 136 9.5450 120 0.1735 145
121 044 SHESTOPALOV 55 -19.7420 151 -0.3589 128 8.7660 121 0.1594 146
122 397 CIRB 31 -2.7160 108 -0.0876 110 8.5760 122 0.2766 118
123 505 Valencia-Alfonso 32 -8.3030 132 -0.2595 127 8.2070 123 0.2565 124
124 488 Preissner 24 3.0050 87 0.1252 84 7.5910 124 0.3163 105
125 377 THW-FR 72 -34.1710 168 -0.4746 138 7.2830 125 0.1012 158
126 136 RPFOLD/Raghava-Gajendra 49 -32.4690 167 -0.6626 150 7.2040 126 0.1470 147
127 334 MZ-Brussels-serv 16 -2.8750 109 -0.1797 119 7.1820 127 0.4489 55
128 314 Scheraga-Harold 26 -21.3840 155 -0.8225 166 6.7740 128 0.2605 121
129 054 Raghava-Gajendara 48 -30.1900 163 -0.6290 148 6.6590 129 0.1387 149
130 270 Solovyev-Softberry 79 -50.9660 180 -0.6371 149 6.6360 130 0.0829 162
131 021 Baldi 76 -83.0430 187 -1.0927 176 6.5570 131 0.0863 160
132 583 MOCOBEX 12 6.4830 77 0.5403 22 6.4830 132 0.5403 38
133 140 PROTINFO-AB 30 -30.2820 164 -1.0094 174 6.4480 133 0.2149 132
134 344 ITSM 25 0.8870 91 0.0355 98 6.4260 134 0.2570 123
135 051 SAMUDRALA-NF 19 -15.3430 141 -0.8075 162 6.2500 135 0.3289 98
136 524 Benner-steve 19 3.6370 85 0.1914 70 6.0480 136 0.3183 103
137 271 Head-Gordon 16 -2.3730 105 -0.1483 117 5.7280 137 0.3580 88
138 131 Bystroff 24 -0.1750 103 -0.0073 103 5.7020 138 0.2376 127
139 052 SAMUDRALA-FR 78 -90.1980 188 -1.1564 178 5.6150 139 0.0720 167
140 139 PROTINFO-FR 80 -92.8240 190 -1.1603 179 5.6150 139 0.0702 168
141 282 Protfinder 74 -65.8200 185 -0.8895 169 5.5840 141 0.0755 166
142 142 Tsunami-serv 70 -56.5910 183 -0.8084 163 5.5520 142 0.0793 163
143 283 Protfinder 58 -54.8930 182 -0.9464 172 4.9700 143 0.0857 161
144 272 Head-Gordon-1 9 3.7840 84 0.4204 41 4.8800 144 0.5422 37
145 188 harrison 27 -6.1320 126 -0.2271 125 4.8540 145 0.1798 140
146 294 Wolynes-Schulten 10 -5.0650 118 -0.5065 140 4.8500 146 0.4850 47
147 391 Lund-Ole 46 -36.0360 169 -0.7834 160 4.7920 147 0.1042 157
148 240 GERLOFF 6 4.5120 82 0.7520 10 4.5120 148 0.7520 11
149 267 HOGUE-SLRI 57 -25.4360 160 -0.4462 137 4.4300 149 0.0777 164
150 581 Fox-Coleman 34 -22.9020 157 -0.6190 145 3.9220 150 0.1060 156
151 331 SRBI 58 -48.9850 177 -0.8446 167 3.7850 151 0.0653 169
152 064 Aligners 32 -12.8110 140 -0.4003 133 3.7470 152 0.1171 155
153 050 DelCLAB 79 -92.6190 189 -1.1724 180 3.6810 153 0.0466 171
154 231 CNBpred 34 -26.9610 161 -0.7703 158 3.3980 154 0.0971 159
155 470 sezerman 14 -2.7100 107 -0.1936 121 2.9630 155 0.2116 134
156 210 Accelrys 6 2.8620 88 0.4770 31 2.8620 156 0.4770 50
157 299 sp_cadd 4 2.7290 89 0.6823 12 2.7290 157 0.6823 17
158 098 Camacho-Carlos-1 58 -50.7300 179 -0.8747 168 2.5840 158 0.0446 172
159 529 Rykunov-Reva-Tarakanov 71 -65.3760 184 -0.9208 170 2.5840 158 0.0364 173
160 326 INFORMAX 20 -15.6200 143 -0.7810 159 2.4730 160 0.1236 152
161 506 jive 9 -5.5070 122 -0.6119 144 1.8390 161 0.2043 135
162 441 Meller-Adamczak 14 -11.0860 134 -0.7919 161 1.6830 162 0.1202 154
163 481 BIKE-sidhu 4 -0.0080 102 -0.0020 102 1.6740 163 0.4185 62
164 292 Osgdj 19 -17.9820 147 -0.9464 171 1.4720 164 0.0775 165
165 424 Jun_Zhu 21 -11.8570 136 -0.5646 142 1.1140 165 0.0530 170
166 300 Ron-Elber 61 -78.5360 186 -1.2875 181 0.9430 166 0.0155 179
167 124 moe-ccg 5 0.4990 96 0.0998 88 0.9270 167 0.1854 137
168 370 nexxus-delrio 2 0.8540 92 0.4270 37 0.8540 168 0.4270 58
169 249 SMD-CCS 6 -2.5240 106 -0.4207 135 0.8300 169 0.1383 150
170 061 Tsai 26 -21.1510 154 -0.8135 165 0.8270 170 0.0318 176
171 341 Avbelj-Franc 2 0.5470 95 0.2735 61 0.7510 171 0.3755 81
172 589 Dorota 1 0.5660 93 0.5660 20 0.5660 172 0.5660 33
173 015 KGI-QMW 21 -20.5290 153 -0.9776 173 0.5610 173 0.0267 178
174 532 Han-Ram 1 0.5530 94 0.5530 21 0.5530 174 0.5530 34
175 554 bfx-jaya 1 0.4980 97 0.4980 28 0.4980 175 0.4980 44
176 091 Tsunami 14 -15.3510 142 -1.0965 177 0.4780 176 0.0341 174
177 545 Flohil 1 0.3760 98 0.3760 49 0.3760 177 0.3760 80
178 459 Shakhnovich-Eugene 12 -18.0550 148 -1.5046 185 0.3450 178 0.0288 177
179 401 Doniach 8 -5.5230 123 -0.6904 155 0.2720 179 0.0340 175
180 559 Irback 4 -2.8890 110 -0.7222 156 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
181 253 CMap23Dpro 1 -0.7480 104 -0.7480 157 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
182 258 Biokol 3 -3.2450 112 -1.0817 175 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
183 011 Floudas-C.A. 13 -17.0800 145 -1.3138 182 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
184 262 Yoon 16 -23.2270 158 -1.4517 183 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
185 571 FM-AF 5 -7.4080 130 -1.4816 184 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
186 102 Bioinformatics 3 -5.1080 120 -1.7027 186 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
187 403 sk-lab 2 -3.7200 115 -1.8600 187 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
188 582 Jager 6 -11.3980 135 -1.8997 188 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
189 411 Roland-Sundar 2 -4.0000 116 -2.0000 189 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
190 548 Kaznessis 3 -6.0000 125 -2.0000 189 0.0000 180 0.0000 180
The cummulative z-scores in this table are calculated according to the following procedure (example for the "first" models):
1. Calculate z-scores from the raw scores for all "first" models (corresponding values from the main result table);
2. Remove outliers - models with zscores below the tolerance threshold (set to -2.0);
3. Recalculate z-scores on the reduced dataset;
4. Assign z-scores below the penalty threshold (either -2.0 or 0.0) to the value of this threshold.
Protein Structure Prediction Center
Sponsored by the US National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIH/NIGMS)
Please address any questions or queries to:
© 2007-2026, University of California, Davis