CASP1 - CASP9
(* results recalculated with new /updated structure comparison programs in 2019)
Menu
`
TS Analysis : Z-score based relative group performance

    Models:

    • Ranking on the models designated as "1"
    • Ranking on best models

    Groups:

    • All groups on 'all groups' targets
    • Server groups on 'all groups' + 'server only' targets

    Formula and Domains:

      The ranking of groups is based on the analysis of zscores for GDT_TS.
    • easy (TBM)
    • medium (TBM/FM)
    • hard (FM)
 
 
  #   GR
  code 		   GR
  name		   Domains   
  Count		   SUM Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   Rank SUM Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   AVG Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   Rank AVG Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   SUM Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   Rank SUM Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   AVG Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   Rank AVG Zscore   
  (>0.0)
1 386 MUFOLD 77 69.9810 1 0.9088 1 70.3640 1 0.9138 2
2 096 ZHANG 78 69.0390 2 0.8851 2 70.1140 2 0.8989 3
3 470 ELOFSSON 78 68.6930 3 0.8807 3 68.9950 3 0.8846 4
4 490 MULTICOM 78 65.0740 4 0.8343 5 66.0020 4 0.8462 5
5 113 FAMSSEC 78 63.7220 5 0.8169 7 65.0400 5 0.8338 6
6 399 CHICKEN_GEORGE 78 61.7460 8 0.7916 9 63.9520 6 0.8199 8
7 094 MCGUFFIN 78 59.7370 9 0.7659 10 63.4610 7 0.8136 9
8 037 FAMS-ACE3 78 62.5070 7 0.8014 8 63.3630 8 0.8123 10
9 033 RECOMBINEIT 77 63.0200 6 0.8184 6 63.1750 9 0.8205 7
10 016 SEOK-META 77 51.0580 16 0.6631 17 61.7820 10 0.8024 11
11 065 PRMLS 78 51.8430 15 0.6647 16 61.6500 11 0.7904 12
12 380 QUARK 78 58.1750 10 0.7458 12 59.9560 12 0.7687 14
13 361 LEECON 76 57.2520 12 0.7533 11 58.7450 13 0.7730 13
14 429 FAMS-MULTI 78 57.4650 11 0.7367 13 58.7420 14 0.7531 15
15 428 ZHANG-SERVER 78 55.2540 13 0.7084 14 57.3700 15 0.7355 16
16 418 ZHANG_AB_INITIO 78 52.9580 14 0.6789 15 56.1760 16 0.7202 17
17 110 STERNBERG 78 46.3280 19 0.5939 24 55.6610 17 0.7136 18
18 402 TASSER 78 49.5690 18 0.6355 20 54.0900 18 0.6935 19
19 088 SPLICER 78 50.5410 17 0.6480 18 53.4720 19 0.6855 20
20 295 KNOWMIN 78 35.6340 26 0.4568 29 48.6610 20 0.6239 25
21 400 LTB 78 43.6260 20 0.5593 26 48.1490 21 0.6173 28
22 240 TMD3D 74 17.8960 45 0.2418 44 45.7280 22 0.6179 27
23 321 BAKER-ROSETTASERVER 78 36.0870 25 0.4627 28 44.3020 23 0.5680 30
24 104 JONES-UCL 66 39.0310 21 0.5914 25 44.1510 24 0.6690 21
25 419 ZHOU-SPARKS-M 74 34.9860 27 0.4728 27 41.9170 25 0.5664 31
26 119 MULTICOM-REFINE 78 34.5820 28 0.4434 32 41.7310 26 0.5350 33
27 147 GENESILICO 78 8.0350 56 0.1030 57 41.1770 27 0.5279 34
28 300 4_BODY_POTENTIALS 67 29.9290 34 0.4467 30 41.0150 28 0.6122 29
29 002 MULTICOM-CLUSTER 78 34.3260 29 0.4401 33 40.7470 29 0.5224 35
30 408 KEASAR 78 24.4000 40 0.3128 41 40.1850 30 0.5152 37
31 286 RAPTORX 60 38.1520 22 0.6359 19 39.3180 31 0.6553 22
32 449 HHPREDB 78 18.5050 42 0.2372 45 38.9360 32 0.4992 39
33 346 HHPREDC 78 18.5050 42 0.2372 45 38.9360 32 0.4992 39
34 453 HHPREDA 78 18.5050 42 0.2372 45 38.9360 32 0.4992 39
35 077 RAPTORX-MSA 60 37.4440 23 0.6241 21 38.8660 35 0.6478 24
36 215 MULTICOM-NOVEL 78 30.4830 31 0.3908 34 38.1530 36 0.4891 42
37 276 RAPTORX-BOOST 60 36.1470 24 0.6025 22 37.3680 37 0.6228 26
38 365 SHORTLE 57 34.0770 30 0.5978 23 37.3240 38 0.6548 23
39 395 SHELL 78 28.8540 35 0.3699 36 36.8770 39 0.4728 44
40 242 SEOK 77 -0.5900 71 -0.0077 70 35.4670 40 0.4606 45
41 457 CHUNK-TASSER 68 30.2590 33 0.4450 31 35.0840 41 0.5159 36
42 080 MULTICOM-CONSTRUCT 78 24.4820 38 0.3139 40 34.6510 42 0.4442 48
43 174 PHYRE2 78 25.6760 37 0.3292 39 34.5190 43 0.4426 49
44 382 KURCINSKI-KIHARA 77 14.0450 50 0.1824 53 33.3840 44 0.4336 51
45 060 CNIO 36 30.2660 32 0.8407 4 33.3290 45 0.9258 1
46 477 MIDWAYFOLDINGHUMAN 73 14.5770 49 0.1997 51 33.0590 46 0.4529 47
47 192 BIO_ICM 71 -19.2010 108 -0.2704 87 32.5900 47 0.4590 46
48 061 MUSICS-2 63 24.4390 39 0.3879 35 32.3830 48 0.5140 38
49 253 PRO-SP3-TASSER 74 25.8970 36 0.3500 37 32.3290 49 0.4369 50
50 360 SBTJ 74 20.0290 41 0.2707 42 30.9680 50 0.4185 54
51 127 FAMSD 78 16.0860 47 0.2062 49 30.8940 51 0.3961 56
52 452 SEOK-SERVER 78 -8.0110 91 -0.1027 76 30.8600 52 0.3956 57
53 103 SAM-T08-SERVER 73 17.2740 46 0.2366 48 30.6400 53 0.4197 53
54 166 ZHOU-SPARKS-X 78 12.6720 52 0.1625 55 30.6330 54 0.3927 59
55 484 FEIG 73 10.3900 55 0.1423 56 30.2900 55 0.4149 55
56 114 LEE 78 -38.0960 134 -0.4884 109 28.6290 56 0.3670 60
57 236 GWS 78 -33.3500 124 -0.4276 103 27.9970 57 0.3589 61
58 165 GSMETASERVER 69 13.9400 51 0.2020 50 27.1020 58 0.3928 58
59 208 PCONSD 78 3.3900 61 0.0435 63 26.7030 59 0.3423 63
60 273 PCOMB 73 5.3110 59 0.0728 60 24.8300 60 0.3401 64
61 199 MUSICS 58 10.6060 54 0.1829 52 24.5740 61 0.4237 52
62 450 BHAGEERATH_SCFBIO 78 -10.6010 94 -0.1359 77 24.3760 62 0.3125 66
63 056 PCONSM 74 6.6810 57 0.0903 58 23.5730 63 0.3186 65
64 291 PRDOS2 76 3.0930 62 0.0407 64 23.5120 64 0.3094 69
65 307 CHUO-FAMS 78 5.5730 58 0.0714 61 23.3710 65 0.2996 71
66 047 BIOSERF 78 -0.3900 70 -0.0050 69 22.7280 66 0.2914 73
67 035 CNIO-FIRESTAR 47 16.0730 48 0.3420 38 22.3840 67 0.4763 43
68 319 PCONS 70 11.6480 53 0.1664 54 21.6960 68 0.3099 68
69 435 MIDWAYFOLDINGSERVER 78 -5.9160 82 -0.0758 74 21.3760 69 0.2741 75
70 275 INTFOLD-TS 78 -5.4390 80 -0.0697 73 21.0730 70 0.2702 76
71 142 CLEF-SERVER 78 -0.1330 68 -0.0017 68 20.7100 71 0.2655 78
72 302 FALCON-SWIFT 78 -0.8520 73 -0.0109 71 19.9910 72 0.2563 80
73 481 MUFOLD-SERVER 64 1.5770 63 0.0246 66 19.9860 73 0.3123 67
74 366 JIANG_THREADER 78 -32.7640 123 -0.4201 102 19.9180 74 0.2554 81
75 476 FFAS03N 72 -13.6850 101 -0.1901 82 19.1990 75 0.2667 77
76 213 CIRCLE 66 3.9160 60 0.0593 62 18.4570 76 0.2797 74
77 423 BILAB 77 -60.7480 144 -0.7889 121 18.3170 77 0.2379 86
78 218 3D-JIGSAW_V4 59 1.4760 64 0.0250 65 18.0210 78 0.3054 70
79 028 PROFILECRF 78 -17.2860 106 -0.2216 84 17.1260 79 0.2196 93
80 458 BILAB-SOLO 67 -54.1290 140 -0.8079 122 16.9600 80 0.2531 83
81 409 MUSTER 78 -11.2620 97 -0.1444 78 16.9080 81 0.2168 94
82 214 DISTILL 78 -7.8680 90 -0.1009 75 16.8450 82 0.2160 95
83 149 LMU 67 -12.0780 99 -0.1803 80 16.1400 83 0.2409 85
84 001 PROQ2 72 -19.5470 110 -0.2715 88 16.0830 84 0.2234 90
85 186 DISTILL_HUMAN 77 -14.4040 103 -0.1871 81 16.0720 85 0.2087 96
86 345 PRECORS 72 -20.4830 113 -0.2845 90 15.8350 86 0.2199 92
87 063 JIANG_ASSEMBLY 78 -58.6890 143 -0.7524 118 15.5980 87 0.2000 98
88 471 FFAS03 67 -11.0610 96 -0.1651 79 15.4040 88 0.2299 88
89 207 ATOME2_CBS 69 -21.2390 115 -0.3078 93 15.3190 89 0.2220 91
90 403 STRUPPI 77 -24.3240 117 -0.3159 96 13.8060 90 0.1793 102
91 447 SWIFT-HUMAN 74 -35.9730 129 -0.4861 108 13.6630 91 0.1846 101
92 129 MUSICS_SERVER 76 -51.8250 138 -0.6819 117 13.3930 92 0.1762 104
93 461 JSCSLB 54 -13.1570 100 -0.2436 86 13.2690 93 0.2457 84
94 220 CLEF 73 -37.1610 133 -0.5091 110 13.0770 94 0.1791 103
95 018 WOLFSON-SERV 76 -36.4310 131 -0.4794 107 12.5810 95 0.1655 107
96 171 FFAS03SS 67 -21.2230 114 -0.3168 97 12.4760 96 0.1862 99
97 353 SAMUDRALA 77 -106.6410 163 -1.3849 149 12.0190 97 0.1561 109
98 304 MA-OPUS-SERVER 78 -36.3940 130 -0.4666 106 11.4690 98 0.1470 113
99 391 SMEG-CCP 71 -21.8700 116 -0.3080 94 11.3500 99 0.1599 108
100 083 FLOUDAS 48 -15.4850 104 -0.3226 98 11.2710 100 0.2348 87
101 117 3D-JIGSAW_V4-5 43 0.9900 66 0.0230 67 10.9170 101 0.2539 82
102 245 PROTAGORAS 58 -19.4620 109 -0.3356 100 10.7880 102 0.1860 100
103 055 MUFOLD-MD 62 -63.1750 145 -1.0190 132 10.6940 103 0.1725 105
104 420 FFAS03A 69 -20.1230 112 -0.2916 91 10.6470 104 0.1543 110
105 436 PANTHER 61 -33.4780 125 -0.5488 112 10.3570 105 0.1698 106
106 026 LOOPP_AUSTIN 63 -13.7160 102 -0.2177 83 9.6410 106 0.1530 111
107 075 RAPTORX-FM 17 1.3560 65 0.0798 59 9.3420 107 0.5495 32
108 301 CPU_HSFANG 66 -35.3020 127 -0.5349 111 9.0600 108 0.1373 116
109 285 SAM-T02-SERVER 60 -18.5800 107 -0.3097 95 8.9240 109 0.1487 112
110 296 PROQ 61 -16.7640 105 -0.2748 89 8.3790 110 0.1374 115
111 314 LMUSERVER 66 -36.7970 132 -0.5575 113 7.4820 111 0.1134 119
112 244 SAM-T06-SERVER 68 -30.3030 122 -0.4456 104 7.2270 112 0.1063 120
113 297 SWA_TEST 78 -135.6030 166 -1.7385 158 6.3970 113 0.0820 125
114 396 FUGUE_KM 67 -30.2910 121 -0.4521 105 6.1670 114 0.0920 121
115 153 AURORAMBSI 46 -35.2850 126 -0.7671 119 6.0690 115 0.1319 117
116 355 LENSERVER 66 -71.9280 153 -1.0898 138 5.5640 116 0.0843 123
117 074 M4T_2009 17 -0.6260 72 -0.0368 72 5.0600 117 0.2976 72
118 328 PUSHCHINO 58 -45.4900 136 -0.7843 120 4.9130 118 0.0847 122
119 009 BEN-TAL 21 -4.8420 78 -0.2306 85 4.8140 119 0.2292 89
120 084 LENGROUP 78 -91.2320 158 -1.1696 142 4.2050 120 0.0539 129
121 311 ALADEGAP 74 -63.7970 147 -0.8621 124 3.8120 121 0.0515 131
122 029 YUAN-CHEN-KIHARA 74 -72.5760 154 -0.9808 130 3.6720 122 0.0496 132
123 248 MUSICS-2S 60 -49.4590 137 -0.8243 123 3.4360 123 0.0573 127
124 350 RBO-PROTEUS 75 -85.9270 157 -1.1457 140 3.2250 124 0.0430 135
125 257 STAT-PROTEUS 63 -72.8200 155 -1.1559 141 2.9190 125 0.0463 134
126 102 BILAB-ENABLE 78 -140.4710 168 -1.8009 160 2.7290 126 0.0350 137
127 282 TAYLOR 31 -28.4060 119 -0.9163 127 2.5570 127 0.0825 124
128 278 SESSIONS 78 -67.4030 151 -0.8641 125 2.5060 128 0.0321 138
129 160 PPFLD 7 -2.2970 74 -0.3281 99 2.4160 129 0.3451 62
130 173 PCONSR 73 -126.4880 165 -1.7327 156 2.3020 130 0.0315 139
131 347 GOBA_PL_07 19 -10.7400 95 -0.5653 114 2.1550 131 0.1134 118
132 182 SCHERAGA 44 -51.8490 139 -1.1784 143 1.7730 132 0.0403 136
133 206 WAC_LABS 59 -63.5610 146 -1.0773 137 1.4900 133 0.0253 141
134 105 TUM_BIOINF_PRAKTIKUM 7 -4.2630 76 -0.6090 115 1.4460 134 0.2066 97
135 228 YASARA 27 -40.7250 135 -1.5083 154 1.4450 135 0.0535 130
136 014 PLATO 51 -66.5120 150 -1.3042 146 1.2520 136 0.0245 142
137 358 GOBA_WROC_PL 19 -11.7540 98 -0.6186 116 1.0570 137 0.0556 128
138 229 BHAGEERATH 78 -106.1750 162 -1.3612 148 1.0180 138 0.0131 143
139 044 PROTEINSHOP 6 -6.2230 84 -1.0372 134 0.8790 139 0.1465 114
140 184 SMARTFOLD 3 0.7720 67 0.2573 43 0.7720 140 0.2573 79
141 189 3SP-TSAILAB 12 -3.5190 75 -0.2933 92 0.7280 141 0.0607 126
142 289 YANG_KDD 66 -95.2290 159 -1.4429 152 0.7170 142 0.0109 145
143 324 AOBA 75 -147.3640 171 -1.9649 164 0.6360 143 0.0085 146
144 407 UNITED3D 78 -153.4030 173 -1.9667 165 0.5970 144 0.0077 148
145 299 BUJNICKI-KOLINSKI 77 -151.4500 172 -1.9669 166 0.5500 145 0.0071 149
146 373 WOLYNES 41 -54.8400 141 -1.3376 147 0.4610 146 0.0112 144
147 250 REHTNAP 56 -57.5740 142 -1.0281 133 0.4410 147 0.0079 147
148 152 DILL_SCORE 8 -7.1490 87 -0.8936 126 0.3780 148 0.0473 133
149 172 BAKER 78 -153.6370 174 -1.9697 167 0.3630 149 0.0047 151
150 045 POEM 63 -118.8290 164 -1.8862 162 0.3470 150 0.0055 150
151 439 DISCO3 11 -19.6760 111 -1.7887 159 0.3240 151 0.0295 140
152 020 DOKHLAB 34 -65.9530 149 -1.9398 163 0.0470 152 0.0014 152
153 154 JAMMING 25 -35.3470 128 -1.4139 150 0.0230 153 0.0009 153
154 261 PARTHA_BDU_INDIA 1 -0.3630 69 -0.3630 101 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
155 086 DILL_BEEF_SMOOTHED 5 -4.5910 77 -0.9182 128 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
156 269 DILL_SCORE_SMOOTHED 6 -5.8280 81 -0.9713 129 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
157 330 SSEFR 10 -9.9030 93 -0.9903 131 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
158 322 DILL_REMD 7 -7.3280 88 -1.0469 135 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
159 331 DILL_SA_SMOOTHED 5 -5.2720 79 -1.0544 136 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
160 039 DILL_BEEF 6 -6.6990 86 -1.1165 139 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
161 433 DILL_SA 5 -6.0710 83 -1.2142 144 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
162 140 DILL 5 -6.5080 85 -1.3016 145 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
163 444 SCHENK-TORDA-SERVER 18 -25.4910 118 -1.4162 151 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
164 279 MOHAMED_ISMAEL_LAB 19 -28.4210 120 -1.4958 153 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
165 336 SUN@TSINGHUA 39 -64.9700 148 -1.6659 155 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
166 178 FKINITIAL 5 -8.6700 92 -1.7340 157 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
167 362 FORTMANN_SERVER 4 -7.4430 89 -1.8607 161 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
168 424 BATES_BMM 71 -140.7340 169 -1.9822 168 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
169 333 DELCLAB 72 -143.3330 170 -1.9907 169 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
170 170 FOLDIT 34 -68.0000 152 -2.0000 170 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
171 264 ConStruct 39 -78.0000 156 -2.0000 170 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
172 316 LOVELL_GROUP 51 -102.0000 160 -2.0000 170 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
173 042 HANDL-LOVELL 51 -102.0000 160 -2.0000 170 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
174 200 MEILERLAB 70 -140.0000 167 -2.0000 170 0.0000 154 0.0000 154
The cummulative z-scores in this table are calculated according to the following procedure (example for the "first" models):
1. Calculate z-scores from the raw scores for all "first" models (corresponding values from the main result table);
2. Remove outliers - models with zscores below the tolerance threshold (set to -2.0);
3. Recalculate z-scores on the reduced dataset;
4. Assign z-scores below the penalty threshold (either -2.0 or 0.0) to the value of this threshold.
Protein Structure Prediction Center
Sponsored by the US National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIH/NIGMS)
Please address any questions or queries to:
© 2007-2026, University of California, Davis