CASP1 - CASP9
(* results recalculated with new /updated structure comparison programs in 2019)
Menu
`
TS Analysis : Z-score based relative group performance

    Models:

    • Ranking on the models designated as "1"
    • Ranking on best models

    Groups:

    • All groups on 'all groups' targets
    • Server groups on 'all groups' + 'server only' targets

    Formula and Domains:

      The ranking of groups is based on the analysis of zscores for GDT_TS.
    • easy (TBM)
    • medium (TBM/FM)
    • hard (FM)
 
 
  #   GR
  code 		   GR
  name		   Domains   
  Count		   SUM Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   Rank SUM Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   AVG Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   Rank AVG Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   SUM Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   Rank SUM Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   AVG Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   Rank AVG Zscore   
  (>0.0)
1 024 Zhang 123 120.6670 1 0.9810 2 120.9700 1 0.9835 2
2 020 Baker 116 110.5270 2 0.9528 3 112.1000 2 0.9664 3
3 125 TASSER 122 101.6190 3 0.8329 5 102.6240 3 0.8412 5
4 025 Zhang-Server 123 97.6230 4 0.7937 6 99.6960 4 0.8105 6
5 050 SBC 121 88.1230 7 0.7283 11 94.0200 5 0.7770 8
6 568 CHIMERA 122 90.1770 5 0.7392 8 92.9770 6 0.7621 9
7 664 CIRCLE-FAMS 122 89.4820 6 0.7335 9 91.8120 7 0.7526 10
8 651 verify 122 86.6580 9 0.7103 12 89.4480 8 0.7332 12
9 005 luethy 123 83.3990 11 0.6780 14 88.3500 9 0.7183 14
10 698 MQAP-Consensus 122 85.0970 10 0.6975 13 88.1960 10 0.7229 13
11 038 GeneSilico 117 87.0440 8 0.7440 7 87.7290 11 0.7498 11
12 675 FAMS_ACE 122 81.6310 12 0.6691 15 85.9260 12 0.7043 15
13 113 Bates 122 77.3690 13 0.6342 17 82.6500 13 0.6775 18
14 047 Pmodeller6 123 68.6320 17 0.5580 22 78.0790 14 0.6348 22
15 658 hPredGrp 122 70.6820 14 0.5794 20 77.8060 15 0.6378 21
16 671 FAMS-MULTI 122 70.0550 15 0.5742 21 73.7730 16 0.6047 26
17 026 SAMUDRALA 121 63.4740 19 0.5246 24 71.7590 17 0.5930 27
18 556 LEE 120 63.6960 18 0.5264 23 71.6190 18 0.5919 28
19 013 Jones-UCL 114 69.1660 16 0.6067 18 71.5670 19 0.6278 24
20 004 ROBETTA 122 63.2410 20 0.5184 25 69.9460 20 0.5733 30
21 307 MetaTasser 122 54.8990 22 0.4500 31 68.5620 21 0.5620 31
22 027 SAMUDRALA-AB 121 59.3360 21 0.4904 27 65.5950 22 0.5421 33
23 214 BayesHH 122 48.3240 31 0.3961 41 65.0000 23 0.5328 34
24 710 Ligand-Circle 105 50.9020 26 0.4848 28 64.9450 24 0.6185 25
25 018 LUO 111 53.2740 24 0.4799 29 61.4280 25 0.5534 32
26 213 HHpred2 116 44.9070 33 0.3871 42 61.3090 26 0.5285 35
27 046 Pcons6 123 53.7280 23 0.4368 33 61.0420 27 0.4963 39
28 010 SAM-T06 123 50.2600 27 0.4086 38 60.2340 28 0.4897 40
29 276 keasar 122 50.2600 27 0.4120 36 59.3940 29 0.4868 41
30 298 CIRCLE 122 51.4790 25 0.4220 35 59.2740 30 0.4859 42
31 439 Sternberg 121 49.6650 29 0.4105 37 58.4180 31 0.4828 43
32 418 HHpred3 115 43.6700 36 0.3797 44 57.7540 32 0.5022 36
33 034 ROKKO 119 42.0650 38 0.3535 49 56.1890 33 0.4722 46
34 105 andante 112 49.4350 30 0.4414 32 56.1660 34 0.5015 37
35 349 FAMSD 122 46.9620 32 0.3849 43 54.4410 35 0.4462 47
36 267 RAPTOR-ACE 122 44.1690 34 0.3620 46 53.4270 36 0.4379 50
37 245 UNI-EID_expm 122 34.3920 46 0.2819 62 53.2920 37 0.4368 51
38 351 FAMS 122 44.1010 35 0.3615 47 51.9420 38 0.4258 54
39 416 honiglab 109 43.5470 37 0.3995 40 51.5710 39 0.4731 45
40 248 RAPTOR 122 37.2870 41 0.3056 57 50.6700 40 0.4153 55
41 275 beautshot 122 38.7820 39 0.3179 55 50.4880 41 0.4138 56
42 414 SP3 122 36.5130 43 0.2993 60 49.5960 42 0.4065 57
43 212 HHpred1 114 30.8400 48 0.2705 63 49.5740 43 0.4349 52
44 415 SP4 122 37.0460 42 0.3037 59 49.4810 44 0.4056 58
45 137 3Dpro 122 29.5210 49 0.2420 65 49.3630 45 0.4046 59
46 338 UCB-SHI 113 34.9630 45 0.3094 56 48.2460 46 0.4270 53
47 091 Ma-OPUS 121 38.4820 40 0.3180 54 48.1670 47 0.3981 61
48 337 AMU-Biology 108 35.4410 44 0.3282 52 47.7330 48 0.4420 49
49 383 UNI-EID_bnmx 122 29.0800 52 0.2384 67 47.5220 49 0.3895 62
50 178 Bilab 122 24.6430 55 0.2020 73 45.7150 50 0.3747 64
51 435 RAPTORESS 122 29.0860 51 0.2384 66 45.5640 51 0.3735 65
52 074 SHORTLE 98 32.1300 47 0.3279 53 43.4450 52 0.4433 48
53 029 PROTINFO-AB 121 19.3520 63 0.1599 80 43.1450 53 0.3566 68
54 092 Ma-OPUS-server 122 18.1530 65 0.1488 83 43.1020 54 0.3533 72
55 035 ROKKY 121 20.6680 61 0.1708 79 42.3980 55 0.3504 74
56 347 beautshotbase 119 27.4940 53 0.2310 68 42.3520 56 0.3559 69
57 028 PROTINFO 119 22.0800 58 0.1855 76 42.2810 57 0.3553 71
58 609 GeneSilicoMetaServer 114 29.1790 50 0.2560 64 42.1140 58 0.3694 66
59 136 FOLDpro 122 15.2410 69 0.1249 88 41.4480 59 0.3397 79
60 318 FUNCTION 120 27.3110 54 0.2276 69 41.1200 60 0.3427 75
61 677 UAM-ICO-BIB 108 16.2410 68 0.1504 82 41.0490 61 0.3801 63
62 274 Shub 122 22.6690 57 0.1858 75 40.6990 62 0.3336 82
63 413 SPARKS2 122 23.8370 56 0.1954 74 40.5220 63 0.3321 84
64 389 SAM_T06_server 122 14.7140 71 0.1206 90 40.3890 64 0.3311 86
65 536 Chen-Tan-Kihara 117 21.0650 60 0.1800 78 40.0260 65 0.3421 76
66 469 Phyre-2 120 16.2950 67 0.1358 84 39.7410 66 0.3312 85
67 135 CBSU 122 18.9310 64 0.1552 81 39.5430 67 0.3241 87
68 211 KIST 117 15.1040 70 0.1291 87 39.1420 68 0.3345 81
69 297 MLee 109 8.8550 76 0.0812 95 37.1530 69 0.3409 78
70 087 Pan 123 3.7640 87 0.0306 100 35.4810 70 0.2885 96
71 601 LTB-WARSAW 97 21.2860 59 0.2194 70 34.4940 71 0.3556 70
72 490 lwyrwicz 107 19.8020 62 0.1851 77 33.8720 72 0.3166 88
73 243 UNI-EID_sfst 118 4.4350 84 0.0376 98 33.6170 73 0.2849 100
74 277 keasar-server 116 4.0150 85 0.0346 99 33.1500 74 0.2858 99
75 179 Bilab-ENABLE 121 -0.4180 106 -0.0035 104 32.7400 75 0.2706 101
76 640 jive 113 5.4100 82 0.0479 96 32.4690 76 0.2873 97
77 443 fais 92 3.5630 88 0.0387 97 31.4410 77 0.3417 77
78 599 KORO 46 13.1470 72 0.2858 61 31.3960 78 0.6825 17
79 261 mGen-3D 105 13.0510 73 0.1243 89 30.5940 79 0.2914 95
80 083 LOOPP 121 2.2750 91 0.0188 101 29.9990 80 0.2479 104
81 103 Huber-Torda 119 -0.3120 104 -0.0026 103 29.2020 81 0.2454 105
82 209 NanoDesign 96 8.2210 77 0.0856 94 28.9570 82 0.3016 92
83 205 NanoModel 122 -6.1080 125 -0.0501 109 28.5530 83 0.2340 109
84 319 FUGMOD 111 -0.7910 110 -0.0071 105 27.2100 84 0.2451 106
85 132 Softberry 116 -13.0890 137 -0.1128 114 27.1160 85 0.2338 110
86 654 NN_PUT_lab 118 -2.0540 115 -0.0174 107 26.6070 86 0.2255 112
87 021 karypis 86 -10.5000 134 -0.1221 115 26.0230 87 0.3026 91
88 063 FEIG 121 -15.9270 140 -0.1316 117 25.4990 88 0.2107 116
89 111 panther 81 16.5400 66 0.2042 72 25.3500 89 0.3130 90
90 186 CaspIta-FOX 121 -19.8210 145 -0.1638 121 25.3430 90 0.2094 117
91 728 Ma-OPUS-server2 77 7.9700 78 0.1035 93 24.2810 91 0.3153 89
92 022 karypis.srv 100 -20.2330 147 -0.2023 127 22.8980 92 0.2290 111
93 706 TENETA 118 -21.3350 150 -0.1808 124 21.2470 93 0.1801 122
94 381 SAM-T02 115 -20.8470 149 -0.1813 125 21.1990 94 0.1843 120
95 242 FUGUE 119 -18.9670 144 -0.1594 119 20.9230 95 0.1758 123
96 380 SAM-T99 94 -5.9030 124 -0.0628 111 20.8760 96 0.2221 113
97 239 nFOLD 111 -18.0350 143 -0.1625 120 20.1480 97 0.1815 121
98 268 karypis.srv.2 95 -17.0430 142 -0.1794 122 20.0990 98 0.2116 115
99 468 Phyre-1 114 -24.7930 153 -0.2175 129 19.4680 99 0.1708 124
100 197 MTUNIC 117 -67.5210 171 -0.5771 147 18.8580 100 0.1612 126
101 208 Nano3D 70 -0.7140 109 -0.0102 106 18.7620 101 0.2680 102
102 247 3D-JIGSAW_POPULUS 117 -25.4160 154 -0.2172 128 18.1680 102 0.1553 129
103 203 forecast 117 -64.9990 170 -0.5555 146 17.5070 103 0.1496 133
104 316 FORTE2 123 -51.4600 166 -0.4184 139 17.3740 104 0.1413 136
105 102 Huber-Torda-Server 119 -57.3500 167 -0.4819 143 17.2910 105 0.1453 135
106 139 ABIpro 121 -145.4180 184 -1.2018 171 16.5310 106 0.1366 139
107 420 3D-JIGSAW_RECOM 116 -32.2630 159 -0.2781 131 16.0990 107 0.1388 137
108 033 POEM-REFINE 25 7.6170 80 0.3047 58 15.7550 108 0.6302 23
109 401 MIG 102 -30.9260 157 -0.3032 132 15.6970 109 0.1539 131
110 705 Akagi 115 -44.5640 164 -0.3875 136 15.2200 110 0.1323 141
111 257 FORTE1 123 -50.1460 165 -0.4077 138 14.8200 111 0.1205 144
112 302 3D-JIGSAW 116 -39.9870 163 -0.3447 133 12.7320 112 0.1098 146
113 333 forecast-s 114 -73.9820 173 -0.6490 150 12.4110 113 0.1089 147
114 393 Distill_human 122 -97.6860 179 -0.8007 158 12.0920 114 0.0991 151
115 168 Distill 122 -99.1650 180 -0.8128 159 11.5030 115 0.0943 152
116 614 Brooks_caspr 23 9.7180 75 0.4225 34 11.4310 116 0.4970 38
117 250 fleil 78 -36.5540 161 -0.4686 141 11.3880 117 0.1460 134
118 249 taylor 46 -3.8620 119 -0.0840 112 11.0560 118 0.2403 108
119 191 Schomburg-group 21 10.0100 74 0.4767 30 10.0100 119 0.4767 44
120 564 ShakSkol-AbInitio 15 7.4300 81 0.4953 26 9.8000 120 0.6533 20
121 494 CPHmodels 61 -24.3870 152 -0.3998 137 8.4320 121 0.1382 138
122 040 YASARA 23 7.6420 79 0.3323 51 8.1150 122 0.3528 73
123 170 LMU 77 -28.6960 156 -0.3727 134 7.9190 123 0.1028 148
124 071 Wymore 48 -10.5760 135 -0.2203 130 7.3400 124 0.1529 132
125 550 ZIB-THESEUS 101 -85.9770 177 -0.8513 162 7.2280 125 0.0716 155
126 757 SSU 24 -3.6710 118 -0.1530 118 7.1280 126 0.2970 93
127 368 Frankenstein 59 -31.6050 158 -0.5357 145 7.1160 127 0.1206 143
128 044 gtg 84 -64.0560 169 -0.7626 156 7.1000 128 0.0845 154
129 121 Peter-G-Wolynes 33 -20.0050 146 -0.6062 149 6.8370 129 0.2072 118
130 064 LMM-Bicocca 26 -1.3610 112 -0.0523 110 6.5220 130 0.2508 103
131 060 HIT-ITNLP 119 -120.4590 181 -1.0123 165 5.5190 131 0.0464 161
132 683 MUMSSP 15 5.3130 83 0.3542 48 5.4320 132 0.3621 67
133 069 panther2 89 -74.7620 174 -0.8400 161 5.3240 133 0.0598 157
134 273 BioDec 61 -35.5390 160 -0.5826 148 5.3190 134 0.0872 153
135 474 PUT_lab 78 -88.5730 178 -1.1356 167 4.9250 135 0.0631 156
136 062 Floudas 28 -13.4980 138 -0.4821 144 4.5020 136 0.1608 127
137 650 Schulten 13 -1.6790 114 -0.1292 116 4.3290 137 0.3330 83
138 194 Scheraga 42 -38.9010 162 -0.9262 163 4.2330 138 0.1008 150
139 721 ROBETTA-late 6 3.8610 86 0.6435 16 4.1790 139 0.6965 16
140 453 Deane 27 -10.2660 133 -0.3802 135 3.5460 140 0.1313 142
141 794 MerzShak 4 2.9260 89 0.7315 10 3.1630 141 0.7907 7
142 427 CADCMLAB 116 -151.7270 185 -1.3080 175 2.9370 142 0.0253 163
143 641 tlbgroup 13 0.0850 102 0.0065 102 2.8810 143 0.2216 114
144 397 Tripos-Cambridge 10 1.0760 95 0.1076 92 2.8670 144 0.2867 98
145 234 McCormack_Okazaki 11 -0.3830 105 -0.0348 108 2.6870 145 0.2443 107
146 586 MIG_FROST 51 -60.5500 168 -1.1873 170 2.5050 146 0.0491 160
147 030 TsaiLab 21 -9.5430 131 -0.4544 140 2.3880 147 0.1137 145
148 224 ricardo 4 2.3640 90 0.5910 19 2.3640 148 0.5910 29
149 011 Dlakic-MSU 7 0.9220 96 0.1317 86 2.0510 149 0.2930 94
150 527 chaos 18 -14.0210 139 -0.7789 157 1.8500 150 0.1028 149
151 495 largo 2 1.8330 92 0.9165 4 1.8330 151 0.9165 4
152 509 SEZERMAN 77 -77.4040 175 -1.0052 164 1.6690 152 0.0217 165
153 559 GSK-CCMM 4 1.6050 93 0.4012 39 1.6050 153 0.4012 60
154 638 Soeding 1 1.4680 94 1.4680 1 1.4680 154 1.4680 1
155 766 ASSEMBLY 2 0.7270 97 0.3635 45 1.3370 155 0.6685 19
156 304 panther3 21 -23.8670 151 -1.1365 168 1.2450 156 0.0593 158
157 464 POMYSL 64 -79.0260 176 -1.2348 173 0.9940 157 0.0155 167
158 109 Cracow.pl 48 -67.6700 172 -1.4098 177 0.8110 158 0.0169 166
159 735 EBGM 14 -9.1270 129 -0.6519 151 0.7070 159 0.0505 159
160 501 Bristol_Comp_Bio 4 0.4780 98 0.1195 91 0.6380 160 0.1595 128
161 193 karypis.srv.4 82 -136.4080 183 -1.6635 182 0.6250 161 0.0076 170
162 263 igor 14 -9.1640 130 -0.6546 152 0.6080 162 0.0434 162
163 588 MIG_FROST_FLEX 3 -2.1750 116 -0.7250 155 0.5030 163 0.1677 125
164 708 MicheleVendruscolo 3 -0.5760 108 -0.1920 126 0.4650 164 0.1550 130
165 016 AMBER-PB 1 0.3380 99 0.3380 50 0.3380 165 0.3380 80
166 043 hu 2 0.2670 100 0.1335 85 0.2670 166 0.1335 140
167 226 Struct-Pred-Course 1 0.2050 101 0.2050 71 0.2050 167 0.2050 119
168 511 FPSOLVER-SERVER 115 -194.4460 186 -1.6908 183 0.1030 168 0.0009 171
169 610 Dlakic-DGSA 3 -1.4130 113 -0.4710 142 0.0670 169 0.0223 164
170 284 Oka 5 -4.0710 121 -0.8142 160 0.0420 170 0.0084 168
171 278 Pushchino 5 -6.2300 127 -1.2460 174 0.0420 170 0.0084 168
172 736 dokhlab 1 -0.1050 103 -0.1050 113 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
173 622 SosnickFreed 3 -0.5390 107 -0.1797 123 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
174 673 ProteinShop 9 -6.1240 126 -0.6804 153 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
175 078 Dill-ZAP 6 -4.3470 122 -0.7245 154 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
176 300 BUKKA 1 -1.0820 111 -1.0820 166 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
177 483 Hirst-Nottingham 18 -20.6790 148 -1.1488 169 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
178 361 Doshisha-Nagoya 9 -10.9380 136 -1.2153 172 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
179 781 SCFBio-IITD 2 -2.7110 117 -1.3555 176 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
180 252 EAtorP 19 -27.6520 155 -1.4554 178 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
181 066 UF_GATORS 4 -5.8340 123 -1.4585 179 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
182 031 Avbelj 7 -10.2390 132 -1.4627 180 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
183 437 osgdj 10 -16.1810 141 -1.6181 181 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
184 746 CDAC 4 -6.8830 128 -1.7208 184 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
185 054 PROTEO 73 -129.8840 182 -1.7792 185 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
186 065 Protofold 2 -4.0000 120 -2.0000 186 0.0000 172 0.0000 172
The cummulative z-scores in this table are calculated according to the following procedure (example for the "first" models):
1. Calculate z-scores from the raw scores for all "first" models (corresponding values from the main result table);
2. Remove outliers - models with zscores below the tolerance threshold (set to -2.0);
3. Recalculate z-scores on the reduced dataset;
4. Assign z-scores below the penalty threshold (either -2.0 or 0.0) to the value of this threshold.
Protein Structure Prediction Center
Sponsored by the US National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIH/NIGMS)
Please address any questions or queries to:
© 2007-2026, University of California, Davis