CASP1 - CASP9
(* results recalculated with new /updated structure comparison programs in 2019)
Menu
`
TS Analysis : Z-score based relative group performance

    Models:

    • Ranking on the models designated as "1"
    • Ranking on best models

    Groups:

    • All groups on 'all groups' targets
    • Server groups on 'all groups' + 'server only' targets

    Formula and Domains:

      The ranking of groups is based on the analysis of zscores for GDT_TS.
    • easy (TBM)
    • medium (TBM/FM)
    • hard (FM)
 
 
  #   GR
  code 		   GR
  name		   Domains   
  Count		   SUM Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   Rank SUM Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   AVG Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   Rank AVG Zscore   
  (>-2.0)		   SUM Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   Rank SUM Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   AVG Zscore   
  (>0.0)		   Rank AVG Zscore   
  (>0.0)
1 489 DBAKER 71 72.1320 1 1.0159 1 73.5210 1 1.0355 1
2 071 Zhang 71 61.4020 2 0.8648 4 61.6530 2 0.8684 4
3 196 ZicoFullSTP 73 57.1000 4 0.7822 7 59.5700 3 0.8160 5
4 434 FAMS-ace2 73 58.5020 3 0.8014 6 58.7530 4 0.8048 7
5 299 Zico 73 55.4310 7 0.7593 9 57.9600 5 0.7940 8
6 426 Zhang-Server 73 56.5040 5 0.7740 8 57.8000 6 0.7918 9
7 057 TASSER 73 54.5230 8 0.7469 10 56.8570 7 0.7789 10
8 453 MULTICOM 73 53.0260 9 0.7264 11 56.6130 8 0.7755 11
9 046 SAM-T08-human 69 55.5940 6 0.8057 5 56.0410 9 0.8122 6
10 138 ZicoFullSTPFullData 73 51.9010 10 0.7110 14 55.2570 10 0.7569 12
11 283 IBT_LT 57 49.3690 13 0.8661 3 54.0330 11 0.9479 2
12 371 GeneSilico 71 50.9410 12 0.7175 13 52.1660 12 0.7347 14
13 379 McGuffin 72 51.8920 11 0.7207 12 52.1430 13 0.7242 16
14 387 Jones-UCL 69 48.3400 14 0.7006 15 51.1320 14 0.7410 13
15 202 Sternberg 71 47.4030 15 0.6676 17 51.0450 15 0.7189 17
16 310 mufold 69 47.1490 16 0.6833 16 50.6850 16 0.7346 15
17 282 3DShot1 72 46.6450 17 0.6478 19 49.9910 17 0.6943 19
18 081 Chicken_George 71 44.8960 21 0.6323 22 49.3940 18 0.6957 18
19 178 Bates_BMM 71 45.9920 18 0.6478 20 48.9880 19 0.6900 21
20 419 3DShotMQ 72 45.6760 20 0.6344 21 48.0520 20 0.6674 22
21 266 FAMS-multi 69 45.7750 19 0.6634 18 47.7980 21 0.6927 20
22 425 BAKER-ROBETTA 73 44.4050 22 0.6083 23 46.9060 22 0.6425 24
23 200 Elofsson 71 39.4880 24 0.5562 25 46.3050 23 0.6522 23
24 442 LevittGroup 69 41.7640 23 0.6053 24 43.6170 24 0.6321 25
25 340 ABIpro 73 38.0210 25 0.5208 26 43.2470 25 0.5924 27
26 208 MidwayFolding 70 36.3930 26 0.5199 28 41.6670 26 0.5952 26
27 182 METATASSER 73 29.7180 31 0.4071 36 39.0500 27 0.5349 31
28 407 LEE 73 31.1010 29 0.4260 33 39.0030 28 0.5343 32
29 012 HHpred5 73 16.1150 51 0.2208 62 38.8930 29 0.5328 33
30 409 pro-sp3-TASSER 73 34.0400 27 0.4663 30 38.8710 30 0.5325 34
31 322 Phyre_de_novo 73 31.0700 30 0.4256 34 37.5530 31 0.5144 35
32 149 A-TASSER 73 29.4430 32 0.4033 37 36.9010 32 0.5055 38
33 408 MUSTER 73 22.0610 34 0.3022 47 36.1260 33 0.4949 40
34 122 HHpred4 73 17.7880 44 0.2437 57 36.0470 34 0.4938 41
35 438 RAPTOR 62 32.2780 28 0.5206 27 35.7190 35 0.5761 28
36 256 SAM-T08-server 73 24.1680 33 0.3311 43 33.3560 36 0.4569 44
37 429 Pcons_multi 71 21.7610 35 0.3065 44 32.8120 37 0.4621 43
38 034 SAMUDRALA 61 20.6590 37 0.3387 42 32.7150 38 0.5363 30
39 020 MULTICOM-CLUSTER 73 20.4510 38 0.2802 51 31.9390 39 0.4375 48
40 351 FALCON 70 16.3130 50 0.2330 60 31.8540 40 0.4551 45
41 154 HHpred2 73 17.9080 43 0.2453 56 31.7850 41 0.4354 49
42 124 POEMQA 72 5.3220 72 0.0739 81 31.1050 42 0.4320 50
43 396 circle 70 15.4590 53 0.2208 61 30.1370 43 0.4305 51
44 013 MULTICOM-REFINE 73 17.7320 45 0.2429 58 30.0850 44 0.4121 53
45 385 PSI 73 20.8940 36 0.2862 50 30.0460 45 0.4116 54
46 235 Phyre2 73 19.4600 40 0.2666 53 29.8820 46 0.4093 56
47 443 MUProt 73 15.4900 52 0.2122 63 28.7080 47 0.3933 59
48 270 Phragment 73 13.6910 54 0.1875 67 28.1980 48 0.3863 62
49 198 fais@hgc 56 19.3520 42 0.3456 41 28.1850 49 0.5033 39
50 384 TJ_Jiang 71 17.5400 46 0.2470 55 27.9790 50 0.3941 58
51 279 GS-KudlatyPred 68 19.6780 39 0.2894 49 27.9300 51 0.4107 55
52 220 FALCON_CONSENSUS 72 5.8290 70 0.0810 79 27.6970 52 0.3847 64
53 131 MULTICOM-RANK 73 11.5060 56 0.1576 68 27.4950 53 0.3766 67
54 436 Pcons_dot_net 67 17.2620 49 0.2576 54 27.3700 54 0.4085 57
55 166 FEIG 70 10.5540 57 0.1508 69 26.8630 55 0.3838 65
56 140 FAMSD 64 19.3740 41 0.3027 46 26.7330 56 0.4177 52
57 174 COMA-M 64 12.0330 55 0.1880 66 24.7880 57 0.3873 61
58 142 FFASsuboptimal 67 9.5580 60 0.1427 71 24.7490 58 0.3694 68
59 369 Jiang_Zhu 71 7.0440 65 0.0992 75 24.4640 59 0.3446 75
60 193 CpHModels 67 6.0970 69 0.0910 78 24.1760 60 0.3608 72
61 069 MULTICOM-CMFR 73 8.6480 61 0.1185 73 24.0420 61 0.3293 79
62 186 Poing 73 6.9760 66 0.0956 77 23.5950 62 0.3232 81
63 048 PS2-server 71 6.9690 67 0.0982 76 23.5750 63 0.3320 78
64 427 3DShot2 73 5.0140 74 0.0687 82 23.5610 64 0.3228 82
65 114 keasar 70 -12.0460 123 -0.1721 108 23.3220 65 0.3332 77
66 475 AMU-Biology 64 17.4330 47 0.2724 52 23.1830 66 0.3622 70
67 023 PS2-manual 69 7.8520 62 0.1138 74 23.1470 67 0.3355 76
68 325 Bilab-UT 71 3.5400 79 0.0499 84 23.0390 68 0.3245 80
69 100 nFOLD3 72 -1.2380 97 -0.0172 94 22.3300 69 0.3101 87
70 253 SHORTLE 48 9.6990 59 0.2021 64 21.1000 70 0.4396 47
71 113 Softberry 71 -4.2760 108 -0.0602 101 20.8180 71 0.2932 92
72 116 fais-server 68 2.1650 81 0.0318 87 20.6910 72 0.3043 88
73 207 POEM 71 -15.5080 127 -0.2184 113 20.5610 73 0.2896 94
74 495 BioSerf 73 4.0650 75 0.0557 83 19.9020 74 0.2726 101
75 415 keasar-server 67 -1.3900 98 -0.0207 95 19.7890 75 0.2954 90
76 007 FFASstandard 67 2.3800 80 0.0355 85 19.6960 76 0.2940 91
77 247 FFASflextemplate 66 0.6570 87 0.0100 89 19.5130 77 0.2957 89
78 135 pipe_int 69 -0.5130 92 -0.0074 91 19.4550 78 0.2820 95
79 284 Hao_Kihara 69 -3.1720 101 -0.0460 97 19.1520 79 0.2776 96
80 085 Frankenstein 65 -8.0640 115 -0.1241 103 19.0520 80 0.2931 93
81 153 GS-MetaServer2 69 -3.9480 106 -0.0572 100 18.9580 81 0.2748 99
82 297 GeneSilicoMetaServer 68 -2.0450 99 -0.0301 96 18.6570 82 0.2744 100
83 337 EB_AMU_Physics 53 6.8440 68 0.1291 72 18.3490 83 0.3462 74
84 493 Kolinski 71 -0.2800 90 -0.0039 90 18.3370 84 0.2583 103
85 143 Pcons_local 68 -3.8340 105 -0.0564 99 18.0380 85 0.2653 102
86 039 PRI-Yang-KiharA 71 -9.7790 118 -0.1377 104 17.9410 86 0.2527 104
87 234 COMA 64 -0.7850 94 -0.0123 92 17.6090 87 0.2751 98
88 267 KudlatyPredHuman 20 17.4200 48 0.8710 2 17.4200 88 0.8710 3
89 296 3D-JIGSAW_AEP 48 7.0680 64 0.1472 70 17.3680 89 0.3618 71
90 349 mGenTHREADER 60 0.8010 86 0.0134 88 16.5110 90 0.2752 97
91 172 FrankensteinLong 49 1.6200 85 0.0331 86 15.5710 91 0.3178 84
92 477 SAM-T06-server 73 -7.1080 114 -0.0974 102 15.3650 92 0.2105 109
93 353 CBSU 40 7.7300 63 0.1933 65 14.7070 93 0.3677 69
94 449 3D-JIGSAW_V3 46 3.6930 78 0.0803 80 14.4020 94 0.3131 86
95 070 fleil 71 -10.6540 121 -0.1501 105 14.3080 95 0.2015 111
96 479 RBO-Proteus 72 -64.0690 152 -0.8898 138 13.9760 96 0.1941 113
97 421 SAM-T02-server 67 -13.6930 126 -0.2044 111 13.6580 97 0.2039 110
98 019 FUGUE_KM 61 -9.8430 119 -0.1614 107 13.4300 98 0.2202 108
99 485 Ozkan-Shell 24 9.9890 58 0.4162 35 12.2260 99 0.5094 36
100 002 ACOMPMOD 67 -26.2120 132 -0.3912 118 12.0380 100 0.1797 116
101 157 3Dpro 67 -18.7050 130 -0.2792 115 11.9790 101 0.1788 117
102 330 JIVE08 45 -9.7370 117 -0.2164 112 10.4600 102 0.2324 107
103 316 forecast 72 -43.7260 143 -0.6073 127 10.1710 103 0.1413 122
104 404 MUFOLD-MD 60 -48.4490 144 -0.8075 137 9.6420 104 0.1607 121
105 119 SAINT 41 -24.4170 131 -0.5955 126 9.5350 105 0.2326 106
106 014 SMEG-CCP 71 -13.2770 125 -0.1870 109 9.2850 106 0.1308 123
107 164 FOLDpro 73 -53.4880 148 -0.7327 134 8.6690 107 0.1188 127
108 454 LOOPP_Server 64 -29.3890 138 -0.4592 119 8.2200 108 0.1284 125
109 461 Sasaki-Cetin-Sasai 46 -28.9990 136 -0.6304 128 8.2160 109 0.1786 118
110 481 Zhou-SPARKS 43 -15.6470 128 -0.3639 117 8.2080 110 0.1909 114
111 293 LEE-SERVER 15 5.2350 73 0.3490 40 7.5860 111 0.5057 37
112 083 tripos_08 28 -0.4160 91 -0.0149 93 6.8760 112 0.2456 105
113 243 Pushchino 52 -28.2050 134 -0.5424 122 6.7990 113 0.1308 124
114 318 panther_server 53 -29.5570 139 -0.5577 123 6.4020 114 0.1208 126
115 147 YASARA 16 3.8190 77 0.2387 59 6.2220 115 0.3889 60
116 403 ricardo 12 5.4730 71 0.4561 31 5.6260 116 0.4688 42
117 394 Fiser-M4T 27 -4.0970 107 -0.1517 106 5.2810 117 0.1956 112
118 356 taylor 15 -0.7020 93 -0.0468 98 4.7110 118 0.3141 85
119 029 Handl-Lovell 24 -6.0940 111 -0.2539 114 4.2800 119 0.1783 119
120 462 MUFOLD-Server 58 -41.0550 142 -0.7078 130 4.2420 120 0.0731 131
121 354 NirBenTal 11 3.9510 76 0.3592 39 4.1690 121 0.3790 66
122 281 huber-torda-server 48 -27.0860 133 -0.5643 124 3.9760 122 0.0828 130
123 463 xianmingpan 59 -29.1230 137 -0.4936 120 3.7960 123 0.0643 132
124 183 StruPPi 70 -51.8190 147 -0.7403 136 3.0140 124 0.0431 138
125 073 Distill 71 -51.0340 146 -0.7188 132 2.6520 125 0.0374 139
126 450 mariner1 51 -56.5750 149 -1.1093 143 2.3990 126 0.0470 137
127 110 ProtAnG 42 -40.1330 141 -0.9555 140 2.3150 127 0.0551 136
128 139 sessions 4 2.0690 82 0.5172 29 2.1710 128 0.5427 29
129 458 Abagyan 6 1.8090 84 0.3015 48 2.1080 129 0.3513 73
130 289 mti 6 1.8320 83 0.3053 45 1.9220 130 0.3203 83
131 373 DelCLab 66 -87.8740 156 -1.3314 147 1.8650 131 0.0283 142
132 093 Wolynes 30 -33.6300 140 -1.1210 144 1.8540 132 0.0618 134
133 095 rehtnap 61 -59.6280 151 -0.9775 141 1.6800 133 0.0275 144
134 213 OLGAFS 52 -71.1580 154 -1.3684 150 1.6520 134 0.0318 140
135 010 Wolfson-FOBIA 7 -3.5920 104 -0.5131 121 1.1490 135 0.1641 120
136 345 mumssp 5 -0.9680 95 -0.1936 110 0.9250 136 0.1850 115
137 211 MeilerLabRene 51 -69.6080 153 -1.3649 149 0.5810 137 0.0114 147
138 272 DistillSN 68 -98.4170 157 -1.4473 152 0.5540 138 0.0081 148
139 420 TWPPLAB 73 -119.9810 159 -1.6436 156 0.4830 139 0.0066 149
140 236 FLOUDAS 39 -28.4840 135 -0.7304 133 0.4810 140 0.0123 146
141 230 TsaiLab 4 -5.5390 110 -1.3847 151 0.4610 141 0.1153 128
142 399 ProteinShop 8 -2.6570 100 -0.3321 116 0.4450 142 0.0556 135
143 470 jacobson 1 0.4410 88 0.4410 32 0.4410 143 0.4410 46
144 170 POISE 14 -10.3480 120 -0.7391 135 0.4340 144 0.0310 141
145 022 reivilo 1 0.3850 89 0.3850 38 0.3850 145 0.3850 63
146 055 NIM2 5 -3.3190 102 -0.6638 129 0.3190 146 0.0638 133
147 005 RPFM 10 -12.4890 124 -1.2489 145 0.2320 147 0.0232 145
148 104 ShakAbInitio 7 -6.6170 112 -0.9453 139 0.1950 148 0.0279 143
149 018 PZ-UAM 2 -1.1620 96 -0.5810 125 0.1790 149 0.0895 129
150 053 mahmood-torda-server 44 -72.1180 155 -1.6390 155 0.1390 150 0.0032 150
151 262 schenk-torda-server 65 -106.2130 158 -1.6340 154 0.1330 151 0.0020 151
152 459 PHAISTOS 5 -3.5680 103 -0.7136 131 0.0000 152 0.0000 152
153 188 igor 16 -16.7340 129 -1.0459 142 0.0000 152 0.0000 152
154 324 Scheraga 39 -50.0750 145 -1.2840 146 0.0000 152 0.0000 152
155 402 HCA 5 -6.7430 113 -1.3486 148 0.0000 152 0.0000 152
156 274 BHAGEERATH 3 -4.7520 109 -1.5840 153 0.0000 152 0.0000 152
157 414 dill_ucsf 7 -11.6040 122 -1.6577 157 0.0000 152 0.0000 152
158 063 psiphifoldings 32 -56.7190 150 -1.7725 158 0.0000 152 0.0000 152
159 382 Linnolt-UH-CMB 5 -9.0360 116 -1.8072 159 0.0000 152 0.0000 152
The cummulative z-scores in this table are calculated according to the following procedure (example for the "first" models):
1. Calculate z-scores from the raw scores for all "first" models (corresponding values from the main result table);
2. Remove outliers - models with zscores below the tolerance threshold (set to -2.0);
3. Recalculate z-scores on the reduced dataset;
4. Assign z-scores below the penalty threshold (either -2.0 or 0.0) to the value of this threshold.
Protein Structure Prediction Center
Sponsored by the US National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIH/NIGMS)
Please address any questions or queries to:
© 2007-2026, University of California, Davis